Real Estate in New windsor, NY
Updated 2026 • Housing market data from 1 zip code • Redfin data through January 2026
📊 New windsor, NY Market Activity
The New windsor housing market shows a median sale price of $442,500, 2.0% higher than last year. The price per square foot is $255, 255% above the national median of ~$215/sqft, up 2.0% year-over-year. Homes in New windsor spend a median of 49 days on market, longer than the national median of 42 days — giving buyers more negotiation room.
🏘️ New windsor Rental Market
The average rent in New windsor, NY is $2,433 per month. A 2-bedroom apartment rents for approximately $2,350/month, while a 3-bedroom home averages $2,800/month.
📦 New windsor Housing Supply & Demand
There are 36 new listings and 38 active properties on the market.
🏆 New windsor Market Competitiveness
Homes in New windsor sell for an average of 100.0% of their asking price. About 46% of properties sell above list price, indicating strong competition among buyers.
On average, homes sell at or above asking price
46% of sales closed above asking, % at or below
📋 Housing Overview
New windsor, NY Housing Market Insights
Delve into the specifics of the real estate market in this area. Understanding key metrics such as the median home price of 475000, the balance between renting (0%) and owning (0%), and a population of 27664 provides valuable insights for potential buyers, sellers, and investors. It is important to note that neighborhood characteristics can vary drastically, and decisions should not solely rely on data available without visiting. Many factors can differ, so do consider inspecting areas in-person to avoid potential mismatches in choice.
Rent vs. Buy Analysis
With a median home price of $475,000 and average rents of $2,433/month, the median household income of $80,000 provides context for affordability in New windsor. Whether you're looking to buy property in New windsor or invest in New windsor real estate, understanding the price-to-rent ratio helps determine if renting or owning makes more financial sense for your situation. A 2-bedroom apartment rents for approximately $2,350/month, while a 3-bedroom house averages $2,800/month.
Economy & What Drives New windsor Real Estate
Real estate values in New windsor, NY are driven by local employment, school quality, and quality of life. The cost of living index of 97.9 (U.S. average = 100) reflects the overall affordability of the area. With a median household income of $80,000, residents have above-average purchasing power. Proximity to major employers, universities, and transportation corridors directly influences home values and demand across New windsor neighborhoods.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- •Lower population density
- •Growing dining options
- •Friendly community atmosphere
- •Good for families with kids
- •Access to outdoor activities
- •Proximity to urban amenities
- •Strong sense of community pride
- •Active local events calendar
- •Historic sites and parks nearby
- •Diverse cultural events available
Cons
- •Job market is somewhat stagnant
- •Few kids activities available
- •Political divide in community
- •Lack of diverse job opportunities
- •Limited nightlife options
- •Some areas have racial tension
- •High cost of living
- •Schools underfunded/overcrowded
- •Higher than average crime rate
- •Limited public transport options
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cost of living in New windsor, NY? ▼
The cost of living in New windsor, NY is 2% lower than the national average, with a cost of living index of 98 (where 100 represents the U.S. average). Housing typically accounts for the largest portion of living expenses. See full cost of living breakdown →
How much does it cost to buy or rent a home in New windsor, NY? ▼
In New windsor, NY, The median home price is $475,000. requiring approximately $144,643 annual income to afford. Average rent is $2,433/month (requiring ~$97,333/year income). The local median household income is $80,000, making homeownership challenging for typical residents. Explore New windsor real estate data →
Is New windsor, NY a safe place to live? ▼
New windsor, NY is relatively safe, with crime rates below the national average. The crime rate is 3.2 per 1,000 residents. Safety varies significantly by neighborhood. View detailed New windsor crime statistics →
What salary do you need to live comfortably in New windsor, NY? ▼
To live comfortably in New windsor, NY and afford a median-priced home of $475,000, you would typically need a household income of $118,750 to $148,438 per year. The local median household income is $80,000. Renting requires approximately $97,333/year (at $2,433/month). See full affordability analysis →
Is New windsor, NY growing? ▼
New windsor, NY has a population of 27,664. As a smaller community, population trends depend on local housing development, job growth, and quality of life factors. The moderately priced housing market and strong job market attract new residents. See New windsor population demographics →
What are the best neighborhoods in New windsor, NY? ▼
The best neighborhoods in New windsor, NY depend on your priorities. For families, look for areas near top-rated schools with lower crime rates. For affordability, neighborhoods farther from the city center tend to offer more affordable options. Explore New windsor on our interactive map →
What is the commute like in New windsor, NY? ▼
Commute times in New windsor, NY vary by neighborhood and workplace location. As a smaller community, residents typically drive, as public transit is limited. The moderate cost of living may allow for housing closer to employment centers. Explore commute times on our map →
How are the taxes in New windsor, NY? ▼
Tax rates in New windsor, NY include state and local components. The cost of living index of 98 reflects a moderate cost environment compared to the national average. View detailed New windsor tax information →
How does New windsor, NY compare to nearby cities? ▼
New windsor, NY offers a more affordable alternative to nearby communities. With a cost of living index of 98, median home prices of $475,000, and a crime rate of 3.25 per 1,000 residents, you can compare these metrics side-by-side. Use the compare feature to evaluate specific cities.
What is the weather like in New windsor, NY? ▼
Weather in New windsor, NY varies by season. Climate data varies by season. View detailed New windsor climate & environment data →
Is it better to rent or buy in New windsor, NY? ▼
With a median home price of $475,000 and average rents of $2,433/month, the price-to-rent ratio in New windsor is 16.3x. This suggests buying is reasonable for those planning to stay 5+ years. See full cost analysis →
What is the price per square foot in New windsor, NY? ▼
The median price per square foot in New windsor is $255, which is 18% above the national median of ~$215/sqft. This reflects the area's demand, construction costs, and proximity to employment centers.
How fast do homes sell in New windsor, NY? ▼
Homes in New windsor spend a median of 49 days on market before going under contract. This indicates homes take longer than the national median of 42 days, giving buyers more negotiating room. View full market data →
Explore More About New windsor, NY
📅 Last Updated: January 2026
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, Zillow, Redfin